
My first thought while I was leaving the theater after watching Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey was, damn, Oppenheimer II was really good.
Silly as that sounds, I don’t think it’s a stretch to consider it a sequel, at least in theme. In fact, Nolan’s not even being subtle about it, especially in the final act of the movie. (Spoilers ahead for a 3,000-year-old Homerian epic.)
When Matt Damon’s Odysseus returns to Ithaca disguised as a beggar, he delivers a monologue to his wife Penelope about the sacrilege of the Trojan Horse. He muses about how it broke the bonds of civilization, turning the beauty of gift-giving into an omen of destruction. To me, there’s a straight line from that monologue to the ruminations of Cillian Murphy’s Oppenheimer, after he used the elegant act of science to split the atom and shatter the world.
Nolan loves heroes who are haunted by their own ingenuity. Men create extraordinary things—a teleportation machine, a crime-fighting persona, a hydrogen bomb, a miraculous statue—and like Frankenstein’s monster, those things become the specters that won’t stop haunting their conjurers. Maybe it’s a metaphor for the burden of craft, that what we pursue as an expression of our genius inevitably devours our world. Maybe it’s Nolan the brilliant, ambitious filmmaker saying he needs to take a vacation.
It’s this long meditation on specific themes that I find fascinating about my favorite artists—what captivates them over their lifetimes, the psychological puzzle they’re trying to solve through their body of work. Sometimes Nolan’s hammer-on-the-nail moralizing and exposition through dialogue bugs me. But I give him a lot of grace, because he’s one of those creators who approaches theme with a steadfast, monastic focus, like the epic poet who inspired this film.
In The Odyssey, more than most of his movies, Nolan lets his lead get introspective about his motives. I’m thinking of the scene where Odysseus ties himself to the mast to endure the Siren’s song, which will probably go down as the most iconic aspect of Damon’s performance.
I loved Odysseus describing the torment of the song—how it awakens not just a carnal urge, but an ineffable yearning at the core of a person. It betrays the noble façade of the desires we wish we had in earnest—like returning home to one’s beloved family and kingdom—and reveals one’s true desire, the one that drives the decades of venturing and tinkering, the one that no venturing and tinkering can actually fulfill.
There’s much to love about Nolan’s Odyssey. The visuals opt for post-apocalyptic scarcity and surreality, bolstering the sense of a world in ruins after the Trojan War. It’s a godless world, one that terrifies and disgusts Olympus enough to never show their faces (save one poignant exception). All that’s left are monsters, witches, and demigods—rendered with fresh, eerie artistry by the filmmakers—each of whom seem as devastated by Odysseus’s sins as the Trojans themselves.
But Odysseus and the Sirens’ song will be the scene that sticks with me. I think it’s because like Odysseus, desire has always been an elusive thing to me, like a ship at the whims of a fickle sea. It gets tossed wildly from one wave to another. It anchors on shores that it shouldn’t. It disappears for ages, like the wind that leaves Odysseus and his men stranded on Apollo’s isle. Rarely can I chart it or reliably navigate by it, but it still foments a deep dissatisfaction that draws me to the sea, venturing and tinkering away.
Sometimes I think it would be nice to tether myself to a post and have it extracted from me by the violence of song, just so I could know without a doubt what my desire really was.
Maybe everybody feels that way. Maybe that’s why The Odyssey endures.

